Trouble in Cincinnati: Key Staff Departures Signal Concerning Direction for Reds

Trouble in Cincinnati: Key Staff Departures Signal Concerning Direction for Reds

By Michael Harrison

February 1, 2025 at 03:34 PM

Troubling signs are emerging within the Cincinnati Reds organization during their playoff push, with several key departures and questionable decisions raising concerns:

Recent Key Departures:

  • Director of Pitching Kyle Boddy (Driveline Baseball founder) resigned
  • Hitting coordinator CJ Gillman resigned
  • Both cited "different direction" as reason for leaving

Earlier Concerning Events:

  • Dick Williams (Head of Baseball Operations) unexpectedly resigned after 2020 playoff appearance
  • Under new leadership of Nick Krall:
    • Traded closer Raisel Iglesias to Angels
    • Non-tendered valuable players Archie Bradley and Curt Casali
    • Attempted to trade star pitchers Luis Castillo and Sonny Gray
    • Let several key free agents walk without adequate replacements

Trade Deadline & Roster Management Issues:

  • Only marginal bullpen improvements made (Luis Cessa, Justin Wilson, Mychal Givens)
  • Failed to address critical shortstop position need
  • Top prospect Hunter Greene remains in AAA despite strong performance and team needs

Pattern of Concerns:

  • Resources being "reallocated" without clear strategy
  • Moving away from analytics-driven approach
  • Weakening of roster despite playoff contention
  • Departure of respected player development personnel

The combination of these events suggests deeper organizational issues affecting the Reds' competitive position and long-term strategy. While the team remains in playoff contention, these developments raise serious questions about the franchise's direction and commitment to fielding the strongest possible team.

Related Articles

Previous Articles