The NFL's highest-paid quarterbacks showed mixed results in the 2023/24 season. Here's how each performed:

1. Joe Burrow ($55M/year)

• 5-5 record before season-ending injury
• Last place in AFC North
• Concerns over recurring injuries (ACL, MCL, calf, wrist)

2. Patrick Mahomes ($52M/year)

• Down year statistically with 14 interceptions
• Still effective in crucial games
• Consistent playoff performer

3. Justin Herbert ($52M/year)

• 5-8 record before finger injury
• Missed playoffs
• 0-1 playoff career record
• New coach Jim Harbaugh incoming

4. Lamar Jackson ($52M/year)

• MVP favorite
• Led Ravens to AFC's #1 seed
• Silenced critics about running style
• Proving worth of contract

5. Jalen Hurts ($51M/year)

• Team collapsed late season
• Lost first playoff game to Buccaneers
• Questions about reliance on "Tush Push" play

6. Aaron Rodgers ($50M/year)

• Injured in first game
• Jets finished 7-10
• Future effectiveness uncertain at age 40

7. Russell Wilson ($49M/year)

• 11-19 overall record with Broncos
• Benched final two games
• Likely ending tenure in Denver

8. Kyler Murray ($46M/year)

• 3-5 record after ACL recovery
• 28-36-1 career record
• Questions about long-term viability

For context, Deshaun Watson (9th highest-paid) went 5-1 as starter (8-4 overall with Browns) despite continued scrutiny over his contract. The 2024/25 season will be crucial for proving his value.

This analysis suggests that even the highest-paid quarterbacks don't guarantee team success, with only Mahomes and Jackson consistently delivering on their contracts.

Related Articles

Previous Articles