The Cincinnati Reds face a significant challenge with Joey Votto's thumb fracture sidelining him for at least three weeks. Here's a comprehensive analysis of potential replacements for their veteran first baseman.

Current Situation:

• Votto is hitting .226 with a .305 OBP
• 5 home runs and 17 RBI this season
• One of only four active players with 1,800+ career games

Replacement Options:

1. Kyle Farmer

• Utility player with 91 innings at first base
• Current season: .173 batting average, 1 HR, 6 RBI
• Limited offensive production despite positional flexibility

2. Alex Blandino

• 29 career innings at first base (17 this season)
• Batting .250 with .368 OBP
• Shows promise with 3 doubles and 4 RBI

3. Mike Moustakas (Best Option)

• Strong middle-of-lineup presence
• Batting .219 with 3 HR, 8 RBI
• Nearly 100 innings experience at first base
• Made 8 starts at first base last season

Recommended Solution: Move Moustakas to first base and implement these lineup adjustments:

• Shift Nick Senzel to third base
• Place Shogo Akiyama or Tyler Naquin in center field
• This configuration maximizes offensive potential while maintaining defensive stability

This arrangement provides the Reds with their strongest lineup option until Votto returns, balancing offensive production with defensive capability.

Related Articles

Previous Articles