Cleveland Browns Preseason Report Card: 5 Players to Buy or Sell

Cleveland Browns Preseason Report Card: 5 Players to Buy or Sell

By Michael Harrison

January 13, 2025 at 07:18 AM

After analyzing two preseason games, here's a comprehensive evaluation of five key Cleveland Browns players showing promise or concern:

DT Jordan Elliott - SELL

  • Restructured contract with lower $1.7M cap hit
  • Only starter to play in Hall of Fame game
  • Outperformed by teammates Togiai, Hurst, and rookie Ika
  • Signing of Shelby Harris further threatens position
  • Continued underwhelming performance since 2020 draft

WR Austin Watkins Jr - BUY

  • 8 catches on 10 targets for 106 yards and 1 TD
  • Strong 6'3" frame with good separation ability
  • Excellent hands and concentration
  • Previous 1,000-yard season at UAB (19.2 yards/catch)
  • Making most of opportunity with other receivers injured

WR Elijah Moore - BUY

  • Acquired from Jets for second-round pick
  • 34% of yards from YAC and designed runs
  • Versatile weapon for quick passes
  • Can line up anywhere in formation
  • Helps stretch field and create running lanes

K Cade York - SELL

  • No competition brought to camp
  • Struggling with sub-50 yard kicks in preseason
  • Only converting extra points so far
  • 75% field goal percentage last season
  • Concerns about performance under pressure

QB Dorian Thompson-Robinson - BUY

  • Impressive stats: 17/21, 194 yards, 2 TDs
  • Added 47 rushing yards on 9 carries
  • Zero turnovers unlike other backup QBs
  • Rising from 4th string to potential backup
  • Shows poise and decision-making ability

Football player running with ball

Football player running with ball

Football player making defensive tackle

Football player making defensive tackle

Football player runs with ball

Football player runs with ball

Football player in running motion

Football player in running motion

Quarterback throwing football during game

Quarterback throwing football during game

Related Articles

Previous Articles