Baker Mayfield's Browns Future: Time to Move On or Extend Contract?
The Cleveland Browns face a crucial decision regarding Baker Mayfield's contract situation. Currently signed through 2022 on his fifth-year option worth approximately $19 million, Mayfield's performance has raised concerns about his long-term future with the team.
Current Performance Analysis:
- 26th ranked QBR (37.9)
- 11 touchdowns, 6 interceptions
- 2,413 passing yards
- Multiple injuries affecting play
- Career stats: 61.9% completion rate, 86 TDs, 49 INTs
- Overall record: 28-28 as starter
Available Quarterback Options:
- Jimmy Garoppolo
- Matthew Stafford
- Derek Carr
- Kirk Cousins
- Sam Darnold
- Nick Foles
- Drew Lock
- Tom Brady
- Lamar Jackson
Key Concerns with Mayfield:
- Inconsistent performance levels
- Below-average TD-to-INT ratio
- Relies heavily on strong defense and running game
- Limited success despite quality weapons (OBJ, Landry, Hooper, Njoku, Chubb, Hunt)
Recommended Solution: The Browns should pursue an established quarterback like Derek Carr or Kirk Cousins who can provide:
- Proven leadership
- Consistent performance
- Stability in a divided locker room
- Competitive edge in a division with Joe Burrow and Lamar Jackson
Unless Mayfield shows significant improvement in his remaining games, Cleveland should look elsewhere for their franchise quarterback. While he may be an NFL-caliber starter, he hasn't demonstrated the ability to lead a team with championship aspirations.